BNO BBS - BNO's Bulletin Board System

TOPICS => THE BOARD => Topic started by: AndyT on November 08, 2013, 05:31:11 PM

Title: Need Help To Find Paper Air Filter To Fit Early PD-4104 Oil Bath Housing
Post by: AndyT on November 08, 2013, 05:31:11 PM
I hope everyone is doing well!

I went to clean the oil bath filters on my 4104 today, and we found that the elements have damaged, mismatched elements. Called US Coach and they have what seems to be a newer style of element. Mine have heavy steel mesh with a removable element on the outside. They are held in place with a long threaded rod that runs through the center and a round plate that installs from below. Tighten the double nuts and you are done.

Has anyone converted this type to a paper element? Do you have a part number?

Someone on the board uses this filter on their 4106: http://www.autozone.com/autozone/parts/_/N-8gcsh?itemIdentifier=247134_0_0_

That feeds a Cadillac engine and I would run 3 of them if they work.

Someone else uses this on a 4106: http://catalog.baldwinfilter.com/  Just put in PA1934

Thanks!


Title: Re: Need Help To Find Paper Air Filter To Fit Early PD-4104 Oil Bath Housing
Post by: AndyT on November 11, 2013, 01:37:13 PM
Looks like when I figure this out I will be the keeper of the knowledge. Hopefully
 I find a solution today.
Title: Re: Need Help To Find Paper Air Filter To Fit Early PD-4104 Oil Bath Housing
Post by: ex4106 on November 11, 2013, 02:16:29 PM
 Andy,, I converted my 06 to that type filter 18 years ago and they are still on the job today. Red Rider and I converted his 06 also two years ago and we are installing the second set in a couple of weeks. You will have to remove the inner "cans" and elements leaving the outer can and lower cover that clips to the bottom. Look up into the outer can and see a circular row of countersunk screws, if they are slotted head you will have to replace them with Phillips heads,(I used stainless)( they need to be flush) Using one 8038 filter installed with the open end up and check the fit  by pressing hard upward to leave an imprint in the rubber seal then check that it will seal.  The bottom "cover" must then have a hole cut out of the center to except the lower sealing surface( just enough diameter to accept the "ridge at the bottom end of the filter)  When properly installed the filter will be trapped when the cover clips are snapped closed...Be aware that the only filter that will fit using this method is the FRAM, a "look a like" from another maker won't fit.>>>Dan
Title: Re: Need Help To Find Paper Air Filter To Fit Early PD-4104 Oil Bath Housing
Post by: georgemci102a2 on November 11, 2013, 02:50:34 PM
Andy,I have been told that the wix filter part #42014 is the replacement if ya wanta go dry.As you said it takes 3.(Just what i was told).hope it is correct info.George
Title: Re: Need Help To Find Paper Air Filter To Fit Early PD-4104 Oil Bath Housing
Post by: AndyT on November 12, 2013, 03:49:33 AM
Thanks for the help guys.

My very early 04 has Philips head screws on a 7" bolt circle that are not countersunk at the top of the "can". I also have a flange that is 4 1/8" dia and close to 1/2 long hanging down. I tried the "8038" type in a Purolator, and that won't seal with the flange there, so there was no easy way to use it. I looked at the Wix #42014 today and it would ride on my screw heads and probably not seal.

I ended up buying 3 cleanable polyester media filters (they don't get oiled) that have a flange on both ends with a 4 1/8" hole, and have a 7" outside diameter by about 7 inches long. They fit right over my flange tightly, clear the screws, and should seal up fine. I will use the stock threaded rod and round sheet metal plate to hold them in and seal the bottom. They were not cheap at $50 each though.  They are Sunshine Air #321-2710k7. They are likely an OEM application that a customer orders from Tennessee Filter Sales in Nashville at the rate of 12 per month. They had 24 in stock!

An old gym sock over the wire mesh I have would do better than what was on there.
Title: Re: Need Help To Find Paper Air Filter To Fit Early PD-4104 Oil Bath Housing
Post by: luvrbus on November 12, 2013, 09:36:57 AM
If that doesn't work out for you just drop a Donaldson Eco Lite 537447 filter in place of the oil bath,other brands like Baldwin,Wix,Fram and others make the same filter

good luck 
Title: Re: Need Help To Find Paper Air Filter To Fit Early PD-4104 Oil Bath Housing
Post by: AndyT on November 13, 2013, 01:33:47 AM
Here's a pic of the filter I purchased. Installation went just fine, and they worked out great. I'm happy!
Title: Re: Need Help To Find Paper Air Filter To Fit Early PD-4104 Oil Bath Housing
Post by: Bill Gerrie on November 13, 2013, 03:26:30 PM
Andy
The filter doesn't look like there is any support around the outside. After the trouble technomadia had with the filter being sucked into the engine I would wrap the filter with a wire mesh that has 1/4" square openings in it. It is sold in a lot of hardware stores.
Bill 
Title: Re: Need Help To Find Paper Air Filter To Fit Early PD-4104 Oil Bath Housing
Post by: luvrbus on November 13, 2013, 06:00:39 PM
Doesn't that filter have a mesh on each pleat I use one similar and it has the wire mesh
Title: Re: Need Help To Find Paper Air Filter To Fit Early PD-4104 Oil Bath Housing
Post by: AndyT on November 13, 2013, 07:40:59 PM
This filter has wire mesh on both sides of each pleat, just like a K&N does. It also has a very heavy expanded metal guard inside. Since the media is cloth and not paper we should have no problem with it being sucked through the intake.

One thing to mention is that you can't see light through it like a K&N gauze filter. I'm very happy with this choice. It was an easy, no mod swap for my bus. Being that mine is #126 I cant be sure that later production models would take the same filter.

Thanks!
Title: Re: Need Help To Find Paper Air Filter To Fit Early PD-4104 Oil Bath Housing
Post by: Bill Gerrie on November 13, 2013, 10:21:03 PM
Andy
Sounds like you picked a good filter. Sorry I didn't see the mesh in the little picture. Didn't want to see anything happen.
Bill
Title: Re: Need Help To Find Paper Air Filter To Fit Early PD-4104 Oil Bath Housing
Post by: AndyT on November 14, 2013, 05:14:14 PM
Andy
Sounds like you picked a good filter. Sorry I didn't see the mesh in the little picture. Didn't want to see anything happen.
Bill

I appreciate you mentioning possible filter issues. I had found other filters that were not reinforced and passed.

We are on a bus run as I type and it seems to be accelerating and handling hills a bit better. I have so much more confidence in having a good quality dry filter supplying my engine. On top of that this conversion required no permanent mods, and I kept the stock air system.
Title: Re: Need Help To Find Paper Air Filter To Fit Early PD-4104 Oil Bath Housing
Post by: siberyd on November 16, 2013, 04:11:02 PM
Andy,

By any chance did you take pictures of your project during the different steps?

I have an oil bath system on my bus, not looking forward to the cleaning process. I like the driving more than the working on of buses.

Siberyd
Title: Re: Need Help To Find Paper Air Filter To Fit Early PD-4104 Oil Bath Housing
Post by: AndyT on November 21, 2013, 10:26:25 PM
I didn't take any installation pictures, Siberyd. There wasn't much to see.  My bus has threaded rod held in place by double "jam" nuts at the top and a round sheet metal plate that seals the bottom of the filter, held in place by jam nuts. I made not mods at all. I can't find a photo of the original setup in my manual, so I assume yours is the same.
Title: Re: Need Help To Find Paper Air Filter To Fit Early PD-4104 Oil Bath Housing
Post by: zimtok on November 22, 2013, 09:50:04 AM
HMMMMMmmmm.

Oil bath clean and change at about $25 for fresh oil.
VS
Paper filter change at $50 x 3 = $150

At that price, I don't mind my oil bath filters...


.
Title: Re: Need Help To Find Paper Air Filter To Fit Early PD-4104 Oil Bath Housing
Post by: lostagain on November 22, 2013, 10:25:53 AM
Used oil works just as good: $0. The oil is just there to catch dirt and dust, which settle the bottom, it doesn't have to be clean to start with.

JC
Title: Re: Need Help To Find Paper Air Filter To Fit Early PD-4104 Oil Bath Housing
Post by: siberyd on November 22, 2013, 10:49:13 AM
You can't beat the price of free. I was looking at the filters as a cleaner alternative when it comes to that time. My skoolie travels about 400 miles a month and my 04 about 100 miles a year.

So I guess I still have time til I have to clean the oil baths.

Siberyd
Title: Re: Need Help To Find Paper Air Filter To Fit Early PD-4104 Oil Bath Housing
Post by: luvrbus on November 22, 2013, 11:27:52 AM
Here straight from DD air inlet system dated 1987 to much to type so I will do just 3 in the difference between oil vs paper air cleaners 

Dry Paper Filters                                                                          Oil Bath Filters

1  98.9 to 99.9% effective regardless of engine speed                    1  96.4 to 98.7 % depending on engine speed d                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           

2 less restriction to air flow                                                        2   Greater restriction to air flow 

3  performance not affected by temperature                                 3   Performance maybe adversely affected by
                                                                                              temperature

there you it have straight from Detroit

good luck
Title: Re: Need Help To Find Paper Air Filter To Fit Early PD-4104 Oil Bath Housing
Post by: pd41044039 on November 22, 2013, 03:07:55 PM
Thanks for that.  The efficiency is closer than I would have thought.
What that tells me is that oil bath was pretty darn good until paper filters passed them by.  If we were on the moon where there were no spare parts, oil bath would do pretty well, but no reason to use them when you can get replacements.
Title: Re: Need Help To Find Paper Air Filter To Fit Early PD-4104 Oil Bath Housing
Post by: luvrbus on November 22, 2013, 03:36:30 PM
The max filtering with a oil bath on a DD takes place at 1328 rpm fwiw
Title: Re: Need Help To Find Paper Air Filter To Fit Early PD-4104 Oil Bath Housing
Post by: siberyd on November 22, 2013, 04:41:21 PM
Luvrbus,

Translation for non mechanically inclined drivers like me please.
Title: Re: Need Help To Find Paper Air Filter To Fit Early PD-4104 Oil Bath Housing
Post by: luvrbus on November 22, 2013, 06:15:21 PM
The DD chart graph show the filtration on a curve from idle to max rpm for the oil bath, not much filtering happens at idle with a oil bath because of the design

good luck
Title: Re: Need Help To Find Paper Air Filter To Fit Early PD-4104 Oil Bath Housing
Post by: AndyT on November 22, 2013, 06:22:15 PM
I switched to a dry filter for a few reasons. My existing oil bath setup was not useable, and I was unable to locate replacement elements. I also considered this an upgrade, and I don't have to mess with dirt caked oil ever again.

The new filters are washable up to 10 times.

So, lets figure my costs:

 $150 for filters reuseable 10 times. That's $15 a per filter cycle. Not bad.